POLEFDN.xls

(4/39)

Description

Pole Foundation Embedment Depth by Five Methods

Finds the embedment depth needed for a free-headed, rigid round pier (pole foundation) carrying horizontal and vertical loads and an applied moment. Because no single method is universally accepted, the workbook offers five on separate sheets so the results can be compared.

Sheets and methods

  • Pole Fdn (Czerniak) – Czerniak/PCA method: L from the cubic L³ − 14.14HoL/R − 18.85Mo/R = 0, with R = Kpγ. Also gives side soil pressures, end bearing, the maximum shear and moment in the pier, and plain concrete stresses to ACI 318-11 Chapter 22. Valid for L/D ≤ 10.
  • Pole Fdn (IBC) – IBC 2012 Section 1807.3.2.1, L = 0.5A[1 + √(1 + 4.36h/A)]
  • Pole Fdn (OAAA) – Outdoor Advertising Association of America method
  • Granular Soil (Teng) and Cohesive Soil (Teng) – USS/Teng method with AASHTO LTS-5, soil strength from the SPT blow count N

Inputs

  • Pier diameter and height above ground, concrete strength
  • Soil unit weight and friction angle (or N), depth to the resisting surface, allowable bearing pressure
  • Axial load, horizontal load and its height, applied moment

Outputs

Required embedment and total pier length, pier weight and bearing pressure, with pass/fail checks and a pressure, shear and moment sketch on the Czerniak sheet.

In the stored Czerniak example (1.5 ft pier, 1.4 kips at 12 ft plus 8.9 ft-kips, φ = 30°) the embedment is 11.67 ft, and two checks fail: end bearing of 11.1 ksf against 2.5 ksf and plain concrete tension of 489 psi against 119 psi. For a 2.5 ft pier with 10.1 kips at 28.6 ft, the IBC sheet gives 14.9 ft and the OAAA sheet 15.6 ft.

Please note

  • Results differ between methods; the Czerniak method is the most conservative. Short rigid piers only.
  • US customary units. Sheets protected without a password, formulas hidden but printed as text. No macros.
  • Written by Alex Tomanovich, P.E. References: E. Czerniak, ASCE J. Struct. Div. ST2 (1957); F. Randall, PCA (1968); IBC 2012; OAAA; Teng and Associates for US Steel (1969); AASHTO LTS-5 (2009).

Calculation Preview

05 Feb 2020
File Size 499.50 Kb
Downloads: 2827
File Version: 2.4
File Author: Alex Tomanovich
File Rating (4/39)

 
Full download access to any calculation is available to users with a paid or awarded subscription (XLC Pro).
Subscriptions are free to contributors to the site, alternatively they can be purchased.
Click here for information on subscriptions.
Comments: 9
atomanovich 9 years ago
I would not recommend using my POLEFDN.xls spreadsheet workbook for the application that you have mentioned. It is really intended for circular shaft-type foundations. You might consider using my FOOTINGS.xls spreadsheet workbook instead. Sorry for my delayed reply. Everything moves a little slower and at a "nice and easy" pace after you retire.
Alex
atomanovich 9 years ago
Dear Mr. Alex,
I have downloaded your POLEFDN. It is excellent program. I have a scenario, for the following conditions;
1. Can these design for Monoblock foundations, where
a. Foundation is 2mx2m (square).
b. Foundation is fully embedded, except for top 300mm which is above ground level.
c. Can units be changes to SI system.
atomanovich 10 years ago
It was brought to my attention that in the "Pole Fnd (Czerniak)" worksheet of the "POLEFDN.xls" workbook that in the section where the plain concrete stresses are checked that I was using the average shear stress and not the maximum value of shear stress for a solid circular cross section. The maximum shear stress for a solid circular cross section is actually 1/3 greater than the average shear stress.
This has been corrected.
atomanovich 11 years ago
gglaubrecht,
You are absolutely right. I was using the "average" shear stress on a circular section (fv = V/A), when I should have been using the maximum value of the shear, fv = 4*V/(3*A), as you pointed out.
Per ACI, the allowable shear stress is Fv = 2*(phi)*f'c^(1/2), where phi is 0.75 for shear. Thus, again as you pointed out, that works out to be Fv = 2*0.75*f'c^(1/2) = 1.5*f'c^(1/2).
Thank you for bringing that to my attention. I will make the corrections and get the update reposted.
Alex
atomanovich 12 years ago
In the "POLEFDN.xls" spreadsheet workbook in the "Pole Fdn (Czerniak)" worksheet it was questioned that the formula shown and used to determine the embedment length (L) was slightly different that shown in the original Czerniak reference cited on the second page of the calculations. The formula that I was using was actually one from the PCA reference where the included coefficients/factors were rounded off to whole numbers as opposed to the unrounded values in Czerniak's original formulas. Since the Czerniak document is what the PCA document is actually based on and what I actually refer to, I made the minor change in the formula for the sake of consistency.
In the process, I also discovered that I had some inconsistency in the variable labeling that was used for the passive resistance parameter. I showed both "R" and "Pp" in different places, so I changed each occurrence of the variable to "R", as was used in the Czerniak reference.
The current version of this workbook is now version 2.3.
hades3 13 years ago
Thanks!
atomanovich 14 years ago
I recently updated the "POLEFDN.xls" workbook, where the "Pole Fdn (IBC)" worksheet now references and uses the IBC 2012 (Chapter 18).
Actually, in substance the IBC has not changed for embedded pole-type foundations since the 2006 version of the Code. Only the table and section designations have changed.
The version of this workbook is now 2.2.
atomanovich 15 years ago
In both the "Granular Soil (Teng)" and "Cohesive Soil (Teng)" worksheets of the "POLEFDN.xls" workbook, I added the calculations for the value and location of the maximum moment in the pole foundation.
This added information was obtained via another reference that I recently came across, AASTO Publication LTS-5 - "Standard Specifications for Structural Supports for Highway Signs, Luminaries, and Traffic Signals (Fifth Edition, 2009). The material in this reference was essentially the same as the original Teng & Associates reference, but included the additional equations for maximum moment and location.
atomanovich 17 years ago
A "glitch" was discovered in the "Pole Fdn (Czerniak)" worksheet of the "POLEFDN.xls" workbook.
I was using a simple iterative approach to solve the polynomial equation for the theoretical embedment depth, "L". In Column V of the worksheet, I have what I term index numbers for each iterative evaluation of the expression to help isolate where the solution converges to zero. Problem was, I had an inadvertent small gap of numbers in the index numbers, and thus they were not completely sequential. One "lucky" gentleman had a design situation where his solution fell at that exact point where the gap in the index numbers occurred, and the solution crashed. Lucky for me he stumbled upon the problem.
This has now been corrected and this workbook is now version 2.0.