BUOYANCY ANALYSIS FOR CONCRETE PIT OR TANK
Description
Buoyancy (Flotation) Check for a Rectangular Concrete Pit or Tank
Checks whether a rectangular concrete pit or tank will float when empty and the groundwater is high. The weight holding it down is compared with the uplift. One sheet covers an open-topped pit; the other covers a buried or enclosed pit with a roof slab below the ground surface.
Method
- Uplift Fb = γw × volume of the structure below the water table
- Resisting weight = concrete (walls, base, roof slab where present, and any grade slab around the pit) + soil above the water table at dry unit weight + soil below it at submerged weight (γsat − γw)
- The soil counted is the wedge rising from the edge of the base overhang at the chosen wedge angle (pyramid frustums, less the pit volume)
- Factor of safety = resisting weight / uplift, reported as O.K. when it is 1.2 or more
Inputs
- Inside length, width and depth; wall, base and grade slab thickness; base overhang; for the enclosed pit, the depth to its top and the roof slab thickness
- Dry and saturated soil unit weights, concrete and water unit weights
- Depth to the water table and the soil wedge angle
Outputs
Soil and concrete weights, total resisting force, buoyant force and the factor of safety.
The stored open-pit example (100 ft × 60 ft × 20 ft deep inside, 2 ft walls, 3 ft base with 3 ft overhang, water table 6 ft down, 30° wedge) gives a resisting force of 11,784 kips against an uplift of 7,256 kips, so FS = 1.62. The enclosed-pit example gives FS = 1.55.
Please note
- Use the highest expected water table and assume the pit is empty. Allow for any soil or slabs that may be removed later. The 1.2 target is the author’s choice; check it against the factors your code requires.
- Soil friction and wall adhesion are not counted beyond the soil wedge. The grade slab is assumed to cover the whole wedge area.
- US customary units. No macros. Sheets protected without a password.
- Written by Alex Tomanovich, P.E.
Calculation Preview
Full download access to any calculation is available to users with a paid or awarded subscription (XLC Pro).
Subscriptions are free to contributors to the site, alternatively they can be purchased.
Click here for information on subscriptions.
Comments: 6
×
9 years ago
Is there an SI version available for this? Standard units are only used in the US and the sheet is locked making it a bit useless for the majority of non US users.
10 years ago
I made some minor appearance/cosmetic changes to the "WALLPRES.xls" and "BUOYANCY.xls" workbooks. What I did was, where same variables existed in both workbooks, I changed the variable names and nomenclature so that they would match up for consistency.
14 years ago
It was brought to my attention in the "BUOYANCY.xls" workbook in the "Enclosed Pit or Tank" worksheet that there was a problem encountered when the water table was located above the top of the pit or tank. The calculation, while in error the way it was, turned out to be conservative for the total buoyed volume when the water table is above the top of the tank.
I have added the necessary program logic to cell C60 in calculating the total buoyed volume to address the condition where the water table is above the top of the tank.
The version of this workbook is now 1.2.
I have added the necessary program logic to cell C60 in calculating the total buoyed volume to address the condition where the water table is above the top of the tank.
The version of this workbook is now 1.2.
16 years ago
It was brought to my attention that in the "Enclosed Pit or Tank" worksheet of the "BUOYANCY.xls" workbook, there were some errors/typos in the input data validation for the input of the Water Table Depth, Dwt, at cell C21. These errors occurred in the "Settings - Validation Criteria", "Input Message", and "Error Alert". None of this had any effect on the resulting calculations. However, this would have incorrectly limited the range of acceptable user input values.
These same errors did not exist in the "Open Pit or Tank Worksheet".
These same errors did not exist in the "Open Pit or Tank Worksheet".
Sorry I took over a year to respond. I've been retired now for a couple of years, so I don't check on this website as often as I used to.
Anyway, I do not have an SI units version of this spreadsheet. However, all of my spreadsheets, including this one, are protected, but not with a password. So you can unprotect it and "massage" it to your liking.
Regards,
Alex