New Comments
×
johndoyle-admin
8 days ago
storm water calculation
Thanks for your contribution I have extended your XLC Pro subscription by 3 months by way of thanks!
17 days ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it was not in English and I could not understand the objective of the calculation. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
2 months ago
Thanks for sharing your calculation I have awarded a three month XLC(Pro) subscription by way of thanks!
3 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it was not in English although it clearly looked useful. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
4 months ago
Thanks for your contribution I have extended your XLC Pro subscription by 3 months by way of thanks!
4 months ago
A very well presented and useful bolt design tool - I have awarded you a free 3 month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks!
4 months ago
Hi John, I am a new member since yesterday. With high hope of start using the tools. Unfortunately not able to set it up properly for the last 10 hours. The error message is attached. Are you able to help. Otherwise can your team provide me a calculation service, I need the calculation urgently. My email is bskwang@singnet.com.sg
5 months ago
You have made a massive contribution to the site and all your work is of such high quality we would like to give you free lifetime membership by way of thanks!
5 months ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
5 months ago
Another great calculation. It is very well laid out. I wish all calculations were as clear and transparent as this. I have extended your XLC Pro subscription by 12 Months by way of thanks!
5 months ago
You recently submitted a calculation to the ExcelCalcs website that we believe belongs to another author. This contravenes out [site rules Rule 9. NO PLAGIARISM](/calcs/good-calc-guide#Publish) - Make sure that you own the calculation. We never want to be accused of plagiarism so you must have the right to give us your calculation. If you have been inspired by other authors please give credit where credit is due. If there are any further uploads of this nature your account will be blocked.
6 months ago
Thanks for sharing your calculation! I have extended your XLC Pro subscription by 3 months by way of thanks.
6 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as there was a number of broken links although it clearly looked useful. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
6 months ago
Puneet. PayPal shows that your payment is pending so until PayPal processes this you are not a paid member. PayPal status says 'Pending until 15 Nov 2024' so until then you don't have access. Sorry the problem is with PayPal and there is nothing we can do but is looks like the issue should be resolved by today.
6 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it was not in English although it clearly looked useful. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
7 months ago
Thanks for sharing your calculation I have awarded a three month XLC(Pro) subscription by way of thanks!
7 months ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
7 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as we encountered errors when we opened the file and it contained illegible characters. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
8 months ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
8 months ago
You recently submitted a calculation to the ExcelCalcs website that we believe belongs to www.islamicacademy.org. [This contravenes out site rule 9 NO PLAGIARISM Make sure that you own the calculation](/calcs/good-calc-guide#Publish). We never want to be accused of plagiarism so you must have the right to give us your calculation. If you have been inspired by other authors please give credit where credit is due. If there are any further uploads of this nature your account will be blocked.
8 months ago
What happens when you don't have any compression steel aside from at the drop panels at columns? Several values won't compute due to division by zero.
8 months ago
Thanks for your contribution I have awarded a 3 month extension to your XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
8 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it was not in English. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
9 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it relates to a specific project of your own and not of general interest to our users. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
9 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it was not in English. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
10 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is not in English. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
10 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is not in English. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
10 months ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is not in English. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
10 months ago
Thanks for sharing your calculation! I have awarded a free 3 month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
10 months ago
We offer free 3 month subscriptions to anyone contributing calculations to the site.
10 months ago
Another great calculation. I have extended your XLC Pro membership by another 3 months!
10 months ago
Thanks for sharing you calculation with us I have awarded a 3 month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks!
11 months ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
12 months ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Thanks for the correction Alex! I have updated the file to version 1.3
1 year ago
laciajames1219,You are correct. The limiting values of Lu and LL should have both been 20' and not 25' as I had inadvertently shown. This error was a 'carryover' from the 2005 version spreadsheet workbook. Figure 9 in the ASCE 7-05 Code had shown the values of 25' for those 2 variables, but those values were revised to 20' in Figure 9 of the ASCE 7-10 Code. When I created the spreadsheet workbook to update from the 2005 Code to the 2010 Code, I obviously missed that. I have updated the ASCE710S.xls spreadsheet workbook to reflect these corrections. I will submit the updated spreadsheet workbook to John so that he can post it on his website. Thanks for bringing this to my attention.Alex
1 year ago
The minimum value for Lu & LL in computing for the drift heights is 20' in ASCE 7-10.
1 year ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Thanks for your contribution I have awarded a 3 month extension to your XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Thanks for your contribution I have awarded a 3 month extension to your XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Thanks for your contribution I have awarded a 3 month extension to your XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is password protected. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks. Sorry it took me a little time to review it.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as I could not understand the geometry, perhaps a sketch would have been useful?. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
[You need to install our XLC software to eliminate #NAME errors.](/support/faqs/repository-downloads-have-name-errors)
1 year ago
Thanks for your contribution I have awarded a 3 month extension to your XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is password protect and I not convinced it is your calculation to publish. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it was not in English and too specific for one of your projects. It would not be of general use to our members. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it was password protected. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is not a calculation but published document that you do not own. This contravenes out site rules https://www.excelcalcs.com/calcs/good-calc-guide#Publish Rule 9. NO PLAGIARISM - Make sure that you own the calculation. We never want to be accused of plagiarism so you must have the right to give us your calculation. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is specific tou your project and not of general use for our members. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is specific tou your project and not of general use for our members. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Ka value is returning error - see the image file attached. Please advise on the fix.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as I do not think it is of interest to our users. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thanks for your contribution I have awarded a 3 month extension to your XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it was password protected. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is not in English and I am unsure as to what code of practise is being followed. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Just added some more details to the calculation preview. This really is an exceptional calc!
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as we already have calculations covering this approach. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
[Cartella](/calcs/repository/Fun/cartella/). I congratulate you on selecting the correct folder for this calculation! Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as I don't think it relevant to our members. [We offer guidance for authors](/calcs/good-calc-guide). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is not in English. We offer guidance for authors on [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site. Would you consider updating the calculation so that is readable in English?
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is not in English. We offer guidance for authors on [/the-good-calculation-guide/](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site. Would you consider updating the calculation so that it is understandable in English?
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the trouble to upload your calculation. On this occasion we have decided not to publish the calculation as it is password protected which is counter to our upload rule '10. UNPROTECTED WORKSHEETS - Keep worksheets and macros unprotected.'. We offer guidance for authors [The Good Calculation Guide](/the-good-calculation-guide/). We hope that this does not discourage you from trying again and thanks for your interest in the site.
Also we noticed some #NAME errors
Would you consider reviewing you calculation to fix these issues?
Also we noticed some #NAME errors
Would you consider reviewing you calculation to fix these issues?
1 year ago
I see that you have correctly identified the author of this calculation, Dr. Mahmoud El-Kateb. This is clearly an extensive spreadsheet covering many topics. Rule 9 for uploads states '9. NO PLAGIARISM - Make sure that you own the calculation. We never want to be accused of plagiarism so you must have the right to give us your calculation. If you have been inspired by other authors please give credit where credit is due.' Can you provide any assurances that you have the permission of the author to upload to this site?
1 year ago
Thanks Aaron that's much better. I have updated your XLC pro subscription by 3 months by way of thanks!
1 year ago
John, updated description is added. I updated the file to make it more user friendly, let me know if that got updated too. Thanks!
1 year ago
Aaron thanks for this but I am struggling to understand how I drive the calculation and exactly what it is doing. I wonder if you could add a little more detail so that I can complete my review of the calculation.
1 year ago
Most of our calculations are working xls or xlsx files and not necessarily templates. The original copy is held here so if you play with a calculation and mess it up you can always download the original from here.
1 year ago
The value of the loads (Pu, Mu and Vu) can be set to any value including zero.
1 year ago
'r' is the position of the centre of gravity of all parts of the vehicle minus the excavator arm itself (chassis, cab, outriggers, wheel and front bucket). None of these parts will move when the boom is fully retracted so the position of 'r' remains unchanged as the geometry of the excavator arm changes. I hope this helps.
1 year ago
I came back after 4 years and I'm trying to use the excelcalcs for embed plates anchor bolts, using this of a column, I thought I can use this one even though is for a beam, I juse won't have axial load. Is that O.K.?
1 year ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
junji999's comment prompted me to review this download page. I have also warded a 3 month XLC Pro subscription to the author. It is well deserved and the author like us all takes inspiration from the eminent author Alex Tomanovich!
1 year ago
I am sorry I seem to have overlooked this when you sent it in September 2023. I have added some details now and extended your XLC Pro subscription by 3 months by way of thanks.
1 year ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
1 year ago
Can you tell me if machine CG 'r' has to be checked @ Boom fully retracted condition?
1 year ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
2 years ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
2 years ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
2 years ago
A useful debut calculation! Thanks for sharing! I have awarded a three month XLC Pro subscription by way of thanks.
